|COOKIES: By using this website you agree that we can place Google Analytics Cookies on your device for performance monitoring.|
Inclusive fitness versus multi-level selection: equivalent approaches to social evolution?
If you have a question about this talk, please contact Oskar Brattstrom.
This talk examines the relationship between two alternative approaches to the evolution of social behaviour: inclusive fitness theory, and multi-level selection. A growing consensus in evolutionary biology maintains that these theories are not really competitors, despite what was once thought, but are in fact ‘equivalent’. I argue that this is correct in a sense, in that it is usually possible to find a correct expression for gene frequency change using either approach. However this only shows that the approaches are predictively equivalent, not that they are causally equivalent. In general in science, predictive equivalent is not usually taken to imply equivalence tout court; and I argue that this general moral applies to the case at hand. I examine a number of examples where either inclusive fitness or multi-level selection seems more ‘causally appropriate’ than the other. I end with a discussion of the suggestion that inclusive fitness is preferable on the grounds that it preserves the ‘individual as maximizing agent’ analogy.
This talk is part of the Behaviour, Ecology & Evolution Seminar Series series.
This talk is included in these lists:
Note that ex-directory lists are not shown.
Other listsFriends of Scott Polar Research Institute lecture series Experience Islam Week 2011 (12th February - 20th February) Cambridge Realist Workshop
Other talksThe role of molecular hydrogen on direct collapse black hole seeds A Look at the Consequences of Internet Censorship Through an ISP Lens Repairing the Dawlish sea wall - Why it failed and how it was fixed Simulating realistic disc galaxies with a novel sub-resolution ISM model Evolution of vertebrate photoreception and retinoid cycle: Clues from the eye transcriptome of basal vertebrates Game of Zones: The Quest for Influence in Europe's Neighbourhood